Showing posts with label Georgia Industrial Ports. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Georgia Industrial Ports. Show all posts

Monday, February 22, 2016

"Port of St. Marys Industrial & Logistics Center"

The comments below have been submitted to the City of St. Marys. We urge all citizens to speak out by sending their thoughts to cdcomments@stmarysga.gov



To: The City of St. Marys Planning Commission, Mayor, and Council
Regarding: Consideration of rezoning proposal re: “The Port of St. Marys Industrial & Logistic Center”
From: Alex Kearns, Chair, St. Marys EarthKeepers
Date: Thursday, Feb. 18, 2016

After careful consideration of the available information regarding the proposed “Port of St. Marys Industrial & Logistics Center” (including the DRI application, response, 2003 Environmental Analysis, the rezoning application, the Staff Report etc.), attending the public meetings, and analyzing the statements made during those meetings, the Board of the St. Marys EarthKeepers has voted to oppose this project and the rezoning required to permit the creation of an industrial bargeport on the site of the former Gilman Paper Company.
While we applaud efforts to revitalize that property, it must be done in such a way as to safeguard the environment and quality-of-life of our citizens – and at this time there are far too many unanswered questions:
- Amount of truck traffic: unknown
- Amount of rail traffic: unknown
- Amount of barge traffic: unknown
- The nature of the industries: unknown (On December 15, 2015, the developer, Mr. Chris Ragucci, stated that he really had no idea what these industries might be but, if we only would approve the rezoning, he was confident that some uses would be found.)
- The extent of the ability of the City to retain the right of approval for such industries: unknown
- The environmental impacts: unknown

- Mitigation plans regarding toxic materials on the site: unknown

We have heard much about how the City will maintain control regarding which industries may be established on the site. It should be noted that the Coast Guard issues permits for the handling of various types of cargoes – and the Coast Guard does NOT notify local governments when permits have been issued. One day the port may be shipping wood pellets, the next day it can be barging crude and flammable bio-fuels and hazardous materials. These materials may sit at a port for an indefinite period of time: in this case, a port that is perilously close to the downtown residential area and the St. Marys Elementary School.  

What is known, from the 2003 environmental assessment, is that the site contains such toxic chemicals as Chromium, Barium, vanadium, sulfuric acid, hydrochloric acid, polychlorinated biphenyl…to name but a few. In order to protect the citizens of St. Marys, the City must stipulate that, before considering rezoning, a comprehensive clean-up proposal must be submitted and thoroughly vetted by experts.

The Planning Commission is charged with analyzing rezoning applications by following a ten-point Zoning Amendment Criteria.

The zoning request should be a logical extension of a zoning boundary which would improve the pattern of uses in general area. We cannot imagine how an industrial barge port could possibly improve the pattern of use in a residential area. Consider the noise, traffic, airborne contaminants, lighting, etc. involved in a large industrial barge port abutting single-family homes. 

The fourth criterion stipulates that “the request should not create traffic which would traverse established single-family neighborhoods on minor streets, leading to congestion, noise and traffic hazards.” The developer has only stated that the amount of truck traffic is unknown although it will be “considerable” and that there will be “lots and lots of trains.” We have been told that primary port access would be along Finley St. What of the residents in that area: their property values, safety and quality of life?

Reviewing the remaining rezoning criteria, many issues and questions arise. Population growth is dependent, in large part, upon the assets and quality of life presented by the city. Will an industrial barge port enhance these factors? That is unknown, and the short-term goal of “offloading” the property could completely destroy any more reasonable future options. 

#9 states “This request should not result in changes to market values and/or tax rates of nearby properties.” It is hard to understand how property values would not be negatively impacted considering the noise, traffic, lights, dust, toxins, the activation of train access etc. involved with industrial bargeports. What impacts will be experienced by the residents of the downtown area in general? Heavy truck and train traffic could impede essential emergency services, impact the infrastructure (roads), and also have an adverse effect on residential property values. 

#10 states “The request should conform to policies and recommendations contained in the St. Marys/Camden County Comprehensive Plan.”
We suggest that everyone familiarize themselves with the St. Marys Mainstreet/Downtown Visioning Plan Feb. 1, 2016, presentation. The City is justifiably proud of the lengths to which it went to gather public input about the direction in which our town should go, existing assets and so forth. Note the prevalence of words like “ecotourism”, “charm”, “history”, “peaceful” etc. In what respect does an industrial barge port with heavy truck and rail traffic, noise/dust/light pollution, and mystery-industries adhere to the stated “vision” for the downtown area?

The “facts” change with every presentation. First Mr. Ragucci spoke of a LNG (liquid natural gas) facility and a pipeline to St. Marys. (He quickly back-pedaled when questioned about his statements to the media about that.) Then he downsized the potential jobs from 5,000+ to “hundreds…maybe. In our dreams.” Then he talked about “wood pellet processing.”

In conclusion, in the face of so many unknown variables, the absence of a clear clean-up plan, and in the light of the expressed will of the citizens of St. Marys regarding the vision for our future, the Board of the St. Marys EarthKeepers respectfully urges the Planning Commission to deny this rezoning request.

Monday, November 30, 2015

Port of St. Marys Proposal




This is lengthy, I know - but I ask you all to spend a bit of time reading...because our community and future is at stake.
There is a proposal being considered by our City Council: The Port of St. Marys Industrial & Logistics Center. We have, in this document, attempted to summarize the primary concerns, provide documented resources, and raise the many questions that must be answered before this project moves forward. We urge you to read the material and attend any and all public meetings about this matter. Ask yourselves what it is that you treasure about St. Marys, and the way in which this project may alter our community. Whether your primary concerns are environmental, economic, quality of life, civic responsibility, or whatever: this issue deserves your active and involved consideration.



Port of St. Marys Industrial & Logistics Center Rezoning Proposal

Prepared by Robert Divine and Alexandra Kearns


Background:

The Port of St. Marys, LLC, has submitted a Rezoning application with the City of St. Marys for the 722 acre tract of land that was the former home of the Durango Paper Mill. The Rezoning application requests a change from the current classification of PD (Planned Development Mixed Use) to a PD (Planned Development Industrial) district under Section 110-68 of the City of St. Marys Zoning Ordinance.  http://www.stmarysga.gov/department/community_development/docs/151109_RezoningApplication.pdf

The proposed development would be known as the “Port of St. Marys Industrial and Logistics Center” and includes a projected redevelopment area of nearly 500 acres with nearly 5,000 linear feet of frontage on the North River branch of the St. Marys River.

The property is currently controlled by a Federal Bankruptcy Court for the estate of Durango–Georgia Paper Company, which ceased operations in 2002. LandMar Group acquired the property in 2005 with intent to redevelop the site into a mixed-use residential and commercial development. The property was rezoned for that purpose, and most of the industrial facilities were demolished and cleared but LandMar went into bankruptcy in 2010 and the property reverted to the bankruptcy trustee.

ASM Capital, a New York-based company that routinely buys bankruptcy debt (a legitimate business) is thought to have done so in this case, thus controlling the creditors committee that must recommend approval of any settlement to the Bankruptcy Court.  ASM Capital apparently has established a subsidiary, The Port of St Marys, LLC, which has a contract to purchase the mill property if the rezoning proposal is approved. http://www.asmcapital.com

Economic Considerations: 

 - Earlier studies indicate that a barge terminal at this site may not be feasible. See the study by Georgia Tech, March 1992, and the study by Georgia Southern University, February 1993, both commissioned by the Development Authority of St Marys.
The Georgia Southern study concluded that a barge terminal would be economically feasible only if the Gilman Paper Company utilized barge shipping for “a significant portion” of their shipments, in and out. Paper manufacturing companies such as Gilman and bulk commodity (gravel, dry chemicals, garbage, etc.) companies produce great quantities of cargo suitable for barge shipping, while very few other industries (including desirable high technology enterprises) generate this type of freight volume. 

- The study also pointed out that “ICW barges fully laden to a draft of 8-12 feet would generally be unable to transit the North River at low water”.  The depth of the North River channel, particularly at low tide, would restrict access to small ICW-type barges that are not suitable for ocean transport. Inasmuch as silting has limited the current ICW depths, north and south of St Marys, only limited intra-coastal transport can be expected.  Regarding the need for dredging, Mr. Christopher Ragucci, the designated representative of the development owner, ASM Capital, has stated that no dredging would be required, although the Georgia Southern study indicated otherwise. Ocean transport would require the added cost of transferring cargo from small barges to larger barges or ocean-going ships at another location, thus impacting economic feasibility. 

- The rezoning proposal is not specific as to the type of industrial development that may be considered. 
 Although the proposal includes building height and set-back restrictions, it does not specify restrictions on uses that may be considered objectionable (noise, odor, light, chemical or other pollutants). Each proposed use will have to be considered by the City before issuing a permit. In each case, the choice will be between jobs for the residents and tax income, versus the possible undesirability of the use - a difficult conundrum for elected officials. In effect, approval of the proposal effectively delegates the economic development of the site, the largest potential driver of economic growth in the City, to a non-resident private company with unknown ultimate objectives.

- The proposal provides building height and setback restrictions, but does not provide requirements for maintaining a favorable visual appearance along Osborne Street or in the Mixed Use commercial area on Meeting Street. The Osborne Street side of the property provides the first view of downtown St Marys. It is crucial that this first impression be favorable to visitors and pleasing to the residents. The re-zoning ordinance should provide for this so that unsightly industrial buildings will not detract from St Marys’ attractiveness.

- Bankruptcy Proceeds: Presumably some of the proceeds from the sale of the property by the bankruptcy trustee will be used to settle claims of creditors, many of whom are St Marys citizens. 
One of the motivations for the City Council to approve the re-zoning application is to provide at least partial payment of claims of its citizens. In order to evaluate the merit of this motivation, the City Council should determine from the bankruptcy court the terms of settlement for each of the various classes of creditors, if the sale should be consummated. This information should be publicized so that citizens/creditors can know what to expect. 

- Port security is handled jointly by the Coast Guard and U.S. Customs and Border Protection, both components of the Department of Homeland Security. Local law enforcement agencies and the FBI also have a role in port security at the local and regional level. The importance of the container shipping industry is equally matched by its vulnerabilities to terrorist attack. Cargo containers represent the largest area of concern in terms of security and vulnerability. With an estimated global inventory of over 12 million, the securing, tracking, and inspection of all shipping containers is a difficult task. The largest obstacle to overcome with cargo and port security is cost: the cost of inspecting the containers, and the cost of shipping delays from those inspections. Will St. Marys' taxpayers be responsible for paying for local law enforcement security efforts at the proposed Port?

Environmental Considerations:

- The Wood Stork Rookery:
The rezoning proposal recognizes the Conservation Area but does not provide for public access for viewing. It should be well-noted that the wood stork is listed as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. What impacts would wide-scale construction, industrial activities, and barge traffic have upon the Rookery?

- Wetlands and salt marsh:
The total property under review includes 165 acres of salt marsh. The property also includes U.S. Army Corps of Engineers jurisdictional freshwater wetlands.

Development is contingent upon “Georgia Department of Natural Resources and USACE permitting.”  Development plan envisions that “3,000 linear feet of barge and vessel berthing is attainable on the North River.”

Will development require dredging of the North River to increase depth, straighten the channel or to provide for a turning basin?  What are assurances that the Georgia DNR and/or the US Army Corps of Engineers (and EPA, if that agency prevails in the currently-proposed jurisdictional claim) approval can be obtained?  Opposition, including legal action, can be expected from environmental groups.

- Increased impervious surfaces and stormwater:
Once the propose development is complete, 75 percent of the site is projected to be impervious surfaces. The “applicant” states that the project will utilize onsite stormwater detention ponds and buffers. It must be determined whether or not these ponds would retain all stormwater from the development or if additional stormwater will be added to the existing system. Additionally, it should be known whether or not the ponds will be discharging stormwater into the adjacent marsh in that any such discharges could negatively impact an environmentally sensitive area.

- Traffic and noise:
The development of a 722 acre industrial, manufacturing and barge port facility will generate greatly-elevated levels of truck traffic and noise. The rezoning proposal projects “Volume Added to Adjacent Streets: 24,998 Weekday Average Daily Trips.” What would the impact be upon the traffic-flow from the downtown historic area and what noise might be experienced by the surrounding residential neighborhoods? 

- Toxicity:
The site in question contains chemicals and toxins. What measures will be taken to protect the surrounding residential area during construction?

- Quality of Life:
It should be noted that during the “public input” periods involved in the formation of the “Main Street/Downtown Strategic Visioning Plan”, the vast majority of respondents cited such attributes as “peaceful”, “charming”, “historic” and “quality of life” when asked about St. Marys advantages and what must be preserved while going forward.

The question facing our elected leaders must be “Will a heavy road, rail, and water traffic industrial barge port at the gateway to St. Marys Historic District serve to protect and promote the unique nature of our community and environment - or will going forward with this proposal be a classic case of “killing the golden goose”?”  

Feasibility:  

There are questions regarding the general feasibility of the development proposal.

Is the developer financially capable of carrying out the plan?

What is its record in similar projects?

Does the developer have audited financial statements, and have the statements been evaluated by competent examiners?

Has the developer ever defaulted in carrying out a similar project? In what other projects is the developer currently involved?

Do any of the principals have a record of illegal activities?  (According to public records and newspaper articles, this is an issue. URL links will be provided upon request.) 

The proposal does not specify any particular intended uses of the property, but earlier statements by the developer suggested consideration of uses that do not appear to be feasible or desirable, including wood pellet manufacturing (There are ten pellet plants currently operating in Georgia, generally located in the center of a circle of available tree raw material, unlike this site which is at the edge of a semi-circle of raw material, thus increasing inbound freight costs because of longer hauling distances; also would result in significant Highway 40 log truck traffic.) It is also quite possible that the manufacturing or export of wood pellets will result in legal intervention: https://www.southernenvironment.org/cases-and-projects/biomass-energy-in-the-south

Mr. Ragucci has also spoken of natural gas interests: “One cargo that’s being explored is natural gas that could be liquefied from a pipeline at St. Marys and put into tank containers for shipment to nearby deepwater ports and distribution to Caribbean customers, Christopher Ragucci, CEO of Worldwide and managing director of the St. Marys project, told JOC.com” http://www.joc.com/port-news/us-ports/barge-port-planned-st-marys-georgia_20141203.html
Kinder Morgan/Southern LNG plans to expand its large facility in Savannah, with direct ocean shipping access, thus avoiding the extra cost of reloading from ICW barges to ocean-going vessels.

The proposal estimates of employment in the 5,300 range appear to be extremely unrealistic. The Gilman Paper mill at this site employed only about 1,000 employees. In general, labor-intensive industries tend to locate in Asia where labor is much cheaper. Increasingly, successful growth industries find ways to utilize fewer employees per output unit, compared to industries such as paper-making which utilize technology developed long in the past. The most desirable technology industries (with minimal pollution, noise, odor and truck traffic issues) generally do not employ large numbers of people in the United States. 

With the limitations of vessel size and carrying capacity, how can this site be competitive with other nearby ports such as Savannah, Brunswick, Fernandina and Jacksonville that do not have similar capacity limitations and are already well-established?

It appears that the developer either does not know or does not wish to reveal what uses are planned. In either event, the “build-out” of the proposed development is very long term (15 years), and the developer’s representative has stated publicly that no significant improvements will be made to the property until at least some of the end uses are known.

Any increase in tax revenues and employment will come at some undefined point in the future. Failure to achieve these desired results may not be confirmed until after many years of missed opportunity to pursue more tangible projects.

In summary, the City of St Marys cannot afford another failed development on this site. This would tie up the property for an additional extended number of years. 

Although there is a natural eagerness to “get something going”, the City Council has a responsibility to the citizens of St Marys to carefully examine the economic feasibility, social implications (quality of life) and environmental ramifications of this proposal AND the capability of the developer, and to approve it only if all relevant questions have been answered in a positive way. It is better to reject a proposal that is not likely to succeed and to wait for a better opportunity, than to buy into an unrealistic proposal with questionable chances for success.

All the above is not an argument against the proposed re-zoning. 

It IS a call for the City Council to do a thorough job of examining all aspects of the proposal, including economic feasibility, specific plans by the developer, past experience by the developer in similar long-term projects, financial capability of the developer, examination of past legal issues of the developer and the developer’s representatives, impact of environmental issues on the developer’s plans, impact of the proposed property sale on the claims of St Marys businesses and citizens on the bankruptcy estate, street-front appearance issues, wood stork rookery issues, traffic issues, water and sewer usage, probability of the developer obtaining necessary  approvals from Georgia DNR, US Army Corps of Engineers and other regulatory bodies, and very importantly, the wishes of St Marys citizens. 

Some City Council members have correctly observed that the property owner (the Bankruptcy Court on behalf of the Durango estate) can sell the property to whomever it chooses - this is not a matter for the City Council to decide. The proposal sale to ASM Capital/The Port of St Marys, LLC, apparently is contingent upon approval of the rezoning proposal, which is subject to City Council approval. 

Thorough and objective research and public answering of the questions raised above may indeed provide good cause to decline this proposal, or it may not. All that is required is for the City Council to have the resolve to seek the answers that will protect and serve their constituents - the citizens of St Marys.

Looking Forward:

Although it should have been done much earlier, perhaps now it is time for the City Council to commission an objective study of the best uses of this property. This property represents the most significant economic development opportunity that St Marys will have for many years in the future.  We cannot afford to waste it!